ODF Alliance finds serious shortcomings in Microsoft
The ODF Alliance, of which the Free Knowledge Institute is a member, has published a Fact Sheet [PDF; also available as text on their website] for governments and others interested in how Microsoft's SP2 for Office 2007 handles ODF. The ODF Allliance says their testing revealed "serious shortcomings that, left unaddressed, would break the open standards based interoperability that the marketplace, especially governments, is demanding". The Fact Sheet itemizes the major problems testing revealed. Marino Marcich, managing director of ODF Alliance, points to one huge shortcoming:
â€œFor example, even the most basic spreadsheet functions, such as adding the numbers contained in two cells, were simply stripped in an ODF file when opened and re-saved in Microsoft Office 2007. A document created in one ODF-supporting application, when re-saved in Microsoft Office 2007, rendered differently â€“ missing bullets, page numbers, charts and other objects, changed fonts â€“ making collaboration on an ODF file with Office 2007 very difficult. Indeed, some of the so-called 'plug-insâ€™ were revealed to provide better support for ODF than the recently released Microsoft Office 2007 SP2. This is no way to achieve the interoperability around ODF that the marketplace is demanding.â€
From the ODF Alliance Fact Sheet:
â€œSupport for ODF represents an important and ongoing test of Microsoftâ€™s commitment to real-world interoperability,â€ said ODF Alliance managing director Marino Marcich. â€œUnfortunately, serious shortcomings have been identified in Microsoftâ€™s support for ODF. Putting potentially millions of ODF files into circulation that are non-interoperable and incompatible with the ODF support provided by other vendors is a recipe for fragmentation.â€
On April 28, 2009, Microsoft released Service Pack 2 for Office 2007 which provided users the ability to open and save ODF files. However, an initial round of testing of Microsoftâ€™s support for ODF in Office 2007 (see analysis at http://www.odfalliance.org/resources/fact-sheet-Microsoft-ODF-support.pdf) has revealed serious shortcomings that, left unaddressed, would break the open standards based interoperability that the marketplace, especially governments, is demanding.
â€œA number of basic interoperability tests between Microsoft Office 2007 and various ODF-supporting software suites revealed that the level of interoperability is far short of what governments around the world are demanding,â€ said Marcich. â€œFor example, even the most basic spreadsheet functions, such as adding the numbers contained in two cells, were simply stripped in an ODF file when opened and re-saved in Microsoft Office 2007.Â A document created in one ODF-supporting application, when re-saved in Microsoft Office 2007, rendered differently â€“ missing bullets, page numbers, charts and other objects, changed fonts â€“ making collaboration on an ODF file with Office 2007 very difficult. Indeed, some of the so-called â€˜plug-insâ€™ were revealed to provide better support for ODF than the recently released Microsoft Office 2007 SP2. This is no way to achieve the interoperability around ODF that the marketplace is demanding.â€
â€œTracked changes are essential to document collaboration, and formulas are the essence of spreadsheets. Microsoftâ€™s failure to support either in SP2 is revealing with regard to its support for real-world interoperability,â€ added Marcich. â€œGiven the shortcomings in Microsoftâ€™s support for ODF, governments need to continue to demand that Microsoft implement support in a manner that plays well with the software of other vendors.â€
Despite these concerns, Marcich cited the growing interest in ODF.Â â€œThe intense, widespread interest in Microsoftâ€™s support for ODF suggests the public debate over document formats is not about to end anytime soon,â€ concluded Marcich. â€œWhat is clear is that the era of public information being locked in a closed format requiring the public to purchase a particular brand of software is rapidly coming to a close, thanks in no small measure to the courage and foresight of leading ODF-supporting governments that have been willing to take a stand on this important public-policy issue.â€
About the ODF Alliance:
The OpenDocument Format Alliance is an organization of governments, academic institutions, non-government organizations and industry dedicated to educating policy makers, IT administrators and the public on the benefits and opportunities of ODF.
MS Office 2007 Service Pack 2 With Support for ODF: How Well Does It Work?
Summary of Initial Test Results on Microsoftâ€™s Support For ODF
Microsoftâ€™s support for the OpenDocument Format (ODF) represents an important and ongoing test of its commitment to real-world interoperability. With SP2, Microsoft instantly becomes the ODF office suite with the greatest market share. Putting millions of ODF files into circulation that are non-interoperable and incompatible with the ODF support provided by other vendors, however, is a recipe for fragmentation, effectively breaking open standards based interoperability on the desktop.
Summarized below are the major shortcomings in Microsoftâ€™s support for ODF that have been identified after an initial round of testing.Â Left unaddressed, they chart a path toward greater divergence instead of the convergence around an open, editable exchange format that the marketplace, including and especially governments, is demanding. Looking forward, a number of recommendations are made to enable Microsoft to make good on its commitment of interoperable support for ODF.
ODF Spreadsheet Interoperability
When reading an ODF spreadsheet, MS Office Excel 2007 strips out formulas, breaking spreadsheet interoperability with all other ODF-supporting applications. While adequate for viewing, Microsoftâ€™s support for ODF spreadsheet collaboration is practically worthless.
-A test spreadsheet created in Google Docs, KSpread, Symphony, OpenOffice, and the Sun Plug-In 3.0 for MS Office, for example, when loaded in MS Excel 2007, failed to process correctly. This is because the formulas used to perform calculations within a spreadsheet (e.g., adding numbers in a column of cells) are simply removed in MS Excel 2007. Instead of performing the calculations, what is left is when the spreadsheet is loaded in MS Excel 2007 is the last value that cell had, when previously saved.
-The same test spreadsheet, when loaded and saved in all the other applications besides MS Excel 2007 (e.g., between KSpread and Google Docs), does process correctly. Most other ODF spreadsheet applications are able to interoperate just fine. The correct approach would have been for Microsoft to do the same to ensure that MS Office users can share spreadsheets with other ODF-supporting office suites.
-The ODF plug-ins for Microsoft Office written by third parties were revealed to provide better support for ODF than the recently released Microsoft Office 2007 SP2.Â MS Excel 2007 will process ODF spreadsheet documents when loaded via the Sun Plug-In 3.0 for MS Office or the SourceForge â€œOpenXML/ODF Translator Add-in for Office,â€ but will fail when using the â€œbuilt-inâ€ support provided by Office 2007 SP2.
-Though spreadsheet formula for ODF 1.0/1.1 (the version which Microsoft claims it supports in Office 2007) are implementation-defined, ODF implementations have nevertheless converged on increasingly interoperable spreadsheets formulas. Microsoft was a voting member of OASIS at the time of ODF 1.0/1.1â€™s approval. ODF 1.2, expected to be considered for approval shortly as an OASIS standard, will define spreadsheet formula using OpenFormula.
-ODF spreadsheets created in Excel 2007 SP2 do not in fact conform to ODF 1.1 because Excel 2007 incorrectly encodes formulas with cell addresses. Section 8.3.1 of ODF 1.1 says that addresses in formulas â€œstart with a â€œ[â€œ and end with a â€œ]â€.â€ In Excel 2007 cell addresses were not enclosed with the necessary square brackets, which could be easily corrected.
Additional Reading: See Update on ODF Spreadsheet Interoperability by Rob Weir/IBM at http://www.robweir.com/blog/2009/05/update-on-odf-spreadsheet.html and On the Microsoft ODF Support Fiasco by Ditesh Gathani at http://ditesh.gathani.org/blog/2009/05/10/on-the-microsoft-office-odf-support-fiasco/
Microsoft Office 2007 does not support encryption (password-protection) in ODF files.
-A MS Office 2007 user with access to the password cannot open a password-protected document created in any of the other major ODF-supporting suites.
-Password protection is an interoperable, supported feature between and among the other major ODF-supporting suites, including KOffice, Open Office, and Lotus Symphony.
-In the other direction, ODF files written in MS Office 2007 cannot be password-protected. MS Office 2007 users are presented with a warning message that you â€œcannot use password protection using the ODF format.â€
-Encryption and password protection are fully specified in ODF 1.0/1.1 (item 17.3 of the specification), so the failure to define this feature in ODF cannot be cited as a plausible explanation. Microsoft should implement support for encryption immediately. ODF 1.2 will come with support for digital signatures. Microsoft should add support for digital signatures as soon as ODF 1.2 is approved.
Additional Reading: See Microsoft now attempts to fragment ODF by Jomar Silva/ODF Alliance at http://homembit.com/2009/05/microsoft-now-attempt-to-fragment-odf.html
Microsoft Office 2007 does not support tracked changes in ODF.
-Tracked changes are essential to collaboration. Failure to include support for tracked changes rules out effective collaboration on an ODF file between users of MS Office 2007 and the ODF-supporting applications that do support this feature, including OpenOffice.org, StarOffice, Lotus Symphony, and Google Docs, among others.
-Tracked changes are specified in ODF 1.0/1.1 so the failure to define this feature in ODF cannot be cited as a plausible explanation. Microsoft should implement interoperable support for tracked changes immediately.
ODF Support in MS Office 2007 Only
MS has not implemented â€œnativeâ€ support for ODF in Office 2003 or its predecessors.
-The vast majority of Microsoft Office users, especially and including most governments, are currently using Office 2003 or its predecessors.
-To receive â€œnativeâ€ support for ODF, MS Office government users will be forced to upgrade to MS Office 2007.
-For users of Office 2003 and its predecessors, Microsoft has promised to continue to support the SourceForge â€œOpenXML/ODF Translator Add-in for Office,â€ and the Sun Plug-In 3.0 is also available to MS Office users. While these plug-ins meet or exceed the performance of Microsoftâ€™s support in MS Office 2007 SP2, they are no long-term substitute for full, native, interoperable support.
Commitment to Support Future Versions of ODF
Microsoftâ€™s announcement concerning the release of Service Pack 2 contains no promise that it will keep its â€œsupportâ€ for ODF up to date with the latest version.
-Microsoft has dragged its feet for over 3 years (ODF 1.0 was approved as an OASIS standard in May 2005 and as an ISO standard in May 2006; ODF 1.1 by OASIS in Feb. 2007), despite repeated calls by governments throughout Europe and elsewhere to implement support for ODF.
-Implementing incompatible, down-level versions of open standards will break interoperability on the desktop, especially considering Microsoftâ€™s potentially large ODF installed user base.
-Microsoft has a rich history of implementing down-level versions of open standards; e.g., Java in Internet Explorer, where Microsoft pre-installed an incompatible version with proprietary extensions and then to let it languish, failing to update it as the Java technology evolved.
-ODF 1.2, which comes with spreadsheet formula, metadata and digital-signature support, will be considered for approval as an OASIS standard soon and has been publicly available on the OASIS OpenDocument Technical Committee (in which Microsoft participates) web site.
-Microsoft and other ODF-supporting vendors should publicly commit to keeping their implementation up to date with the latest version of ODF. A new version of ODF should be required to be supported in any MS Office version or service pack released after the new version of an ODF standard is released.